America After the Midterms, Part 5 of 10.
Every defeated party writes an autopsy. The Republican one is already contested, and the central question is simple: did Trump voters switch sides, or did they stay at home?
Two explanations
Early exit polls suggested some Republican-leaning voters had swung to Democrats, angered by prices and the war. A later analysis by the pollster J.L. Partners, reported by the New York Post and Townhall, reached a different conclusion: more than two-thirds of the Republican slide from 2024 came from Trump supporters not voting at all.
The two explanations lead to very different conclusions. If voters switched, Republicans have a persuasion problem: their policies are unpopular. If voters stayed home, they have a mobilisation problem: their coalition depends on Trump being on the ballot.
The coalition of one man
There is a long pattern here. Trump’s personal appeal brought new and irregular voters into politics in 2016, 2020 and 2024. Those voters turn out for him, but not always for his party. The Latin Times summed up the problem as a party that built its identity around a leader whose appeal does not automatically transfer to other candidates.
This is not unique to the Republicans. Barack Obama’s coalition did not turn out for Democrats in the 2010 and 2014 midterms, and Democrats lost heavily both times.
Loyalty is holding, but softening
Among Republicans, Trump is still popular. An Economist/YouGov poll in mid-November found about eight in ten Republican registered voters approve of him. But the share who strongly approve fell from 48 per cent a week before the election to 40 per cent after it. Reuters/Ipsos put his favourable rating among Republicans at above 70 per cent. Nationally, his approval stood at around 32 per cent in both surveys.
Among younger Americans the decline is sharper. The first post-election Economist/YouGov poll put his approval at 30 per cent among voters aged 18 to 29.
What the Democrats should not assume
If the turnout explanation is right, the Democratic victory may be less durable than it looks. Voters who stayed home in 2026 could return in 2028, especially if a candidate excites them. Democrats won partly because their opponents were demoralised, not only because their own message was persuasive.
There is a warning for the Democrats inside their own ranks, too. Party tensions are already visible: Senator Chris Van Hollen has announced a challenge to Chuck Schumer’s leadership, and progressive and moderate members disagree about strategy.
A lesson for democracies everywhere
Movements built around one personality are fragile. When the leader is not on the ballot, or loses public trust, the movement can collapse with surprising speed. Africa knows this story well. Liberation movements and big-man parties that became vehicles for one leader have often found that loyalty to a person does not outlast that person’s failures. Durable democratic parties are built on institutions, ideas and members, not only on charisma.

Leave a Reply