Europe in Flux, Part 4 of 10.
No issue divides European politics more deeply than migration, and no continent is more affected by Europe’s choices than Africa.
Burnham’s balancing act
Andy Burnham comes from Labour’s more liberal tradition on immigration, but his early decisions as Prime Minister suggest broad continuity with the existing emphasis on border control and enforcement. Asked by ITV whether legal migration was too high or too low, he said it was “difficult to say”.
His government has also launched three new “safe and legal routes”, which Burnham argues will reduce illegal crossings by giving people a lawful alternative. Conservative MP Neil O’Brien argued in The Critic that the government is doing eight different things that will increase immigration, including lowering some salary thresholds for work visas. Supporters reply that Britain’s care homes, hospitals and farms depend on overseas workers, and that safe routes undercut the smugglers.
A new UK-EU front
On 20 November, it was reported that Burnham and Ursula von der Leyen were expected to endorse a joint statement in Brussels creating a structured dialogue on returns. For the first time it will cover third-country hubs for rejected asylum seekers. Burnham said the public want the government to do “whatever we can” on illegal immigration, and that Britain would watch the EU’s arrangements with interest.
Europe’s return hubs
The EU’s new Migration and Asylum Pact came into force in June 2026, bringing faster border screening. That same month the EU agreed a Return Regulation that allows rejected asylum seekers to be sent to “return hubs” in third countries. The Migration Policy Institute notes the debate: some praise the move as pragmatic, while advocates warn it could create legal black holes with weak protections. The countries mentioned as possible partners for such arrangements include Ghana, Rwanda, Senegal, Uganda, Mauritania, Libya, Egypt, Ethiopia and Tunisia.
Paying Africa to stop Africans
Europe has been funding African governments to control departures for years. The EU’s 2024 deal with Mauritania was worth €210 million, and a €30 million agreement with Senegal followed in November 2025. Frontex figures show detections on the West African route fell by 63 per cent in 2025.
But the costs are real. The Mixed Migration Centre reports that crackdowns in Mauritania led to the expulsion of thousands into Mali and Senegal, and that smugglers have shifted to longer, more dangerous routes. A study by the International Centre for Migration Policy Development, itself an organisation that works for European governments, found that stricter borders have reshaped routes without reducing overall departures from Africa.
The case on each side
European governments argue that they must control their borders to keep public consent for migration at all, and that deterring dangerous sea crossings saves lives. Critics argue that outsourcing border control to African governments buys short-term numbers at the price of human rights, and treats African states as Europe’s border guards.
A Pan-African view
Africa should negotiate these deals from strength, not dependence. Any agreement should guarantee legal routes for work and study, protect the dignity of migrants, and bring real investment in jobs at home. The deeper answer is the one Africa must provide itself: economies that give young people a future worth staying for, and free movement within Africa that makes the continent itself a destination.

Leave a Reply