America After the Midterms, Part 6 of 10.
In the AP VoteCast survey, 32 per cent of voters named the state of democracy as the most important issue facing the country, second only to the economy. That is a remarkable number for an established democracy. To understand it, we have to look at how the Trump administration has used the machinery of law enforcement.
A norm that was broken
After the Watergate scandal of the 1970s, the US Justice Department built a tradition of independence from the White House. Under it, prosecutors avoid politically sensitive actions close to an election so as not to influence the vote. The Justice Manual says the department’s powers must be used free from partisan consideration.
In the weeks before the midterms, Axios reported that the department “barrels into midterms with lawsuits, raids and arrests”. The Associated Press described a blitz of politically sensitive cases. These included investigations of prominent Democrats, actions on alleged election fraud, and cases against former officials Trump has long accused of wrongdoing. The non-partisan group States United reported that in the first year of the second term the department opened criminal investigations into the chair of the Federal Reserve, members of Congress and former Trump officials.
The administration’s case
The administration and its supporters reject the charge of political targeting. The department has said it is “following the facts and the law, not anyone’s political timetable.” It argues that the earlier prosecutions of Trump himself were the real weaponisation of justice, and that it is now holding people to account who were previously protected. Trump’s supporters applaud Attorney General Todd Blanche for, in their view, cleaning up a corrupted institution.
Readers should weigh these claims against the evidence. Several of the department’s cases have run into trouble before grand juries and judges. Even the conservative Washington Examiner has warned that politicised cases built on weak legal foundations risk undermining public faith in the department.
After the vote
The post-election tone has not softened. PBS NewsHour reported that the President called Democratic requests for information “extortion at the highest level”. The Attorney General said criminal investigations of Democrats are possible. Incoming House Oversight chair Robert Garcia, for his part, has publicly told administration officials to “lawyer up”.
When both sides talk about the other in criminal terms, a democracy is in a dangerous place. Oversight by an elected legislature is a normal and healthy check on power. Threatening to prosecute legislators for carrying out oversight is not.
The principle at stake
The test of a democratic justice system is simple: would the same action be taken if the target were an ally rather than an opponent? Critics such as The Nation argue that the record shows almost no federal investigations of Republican lawmakers or allies during this term. Supporters respond that wrongdoing is wrongdoing, whoever commits it.
For readers in Zimbabwe and across Africa, this debate will sound familiar. We have watched governments use police, prosecutors and courts against opponents while protecting their own. The American experience shows that no democracy is immune. Institutions survive only when officials refuse to bend them and citizens refuse to accept it. On 3 November, a third of American voters said they were watching.

Leave a Reply