America After the Midterms, Part 3 of 10.
Donald Trump won in 2024 largely on a promise to bring down the cost of living. Two years later, voters judged him on that promise and found it unkept.
What the voters said
The exit polls are unusually clear. In the AP VoteCast survey, analysed by the American Enterprise Institute, the economy was the most important issue for 39 per cent of voters. Sixty-two per cent said higher-than-usual prices were mainly the result of Trump’s policies; 38 per cent blamed factors outside his control. Only 22 per cent said his tariffs had helped the national economy, while 65 per cent said they had hurt it. Voters said Democrats could handle the economy better, 43 per cent to 38.
The Fox News Voter Poll found much the same thing: roughly two-thirds said the tariffs hurt the national economy, and nearly as many said they hurt their local economy.
The case Republicans made
The Republican record was not empty, and an honest analysis must say so. The economy kept growing: real GDP rose at an annual rate of 2.5 per cent in the first quarter of 2026 and 2.2 per cent in the second, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. Border crossings fell to historic lows. Murders fell sharply, with the homicide rate tying the lowest since 1955. Republicans also passed tax cuts and promoted domestic oil production.
In September, the President urged Republicans to campaign on that record and promised they would “win big”. The Associated Press noted at the time that he used significantly inflated figures when describing investment and drug prices.
Why the record did not land
Three things worked against it.
First, tariffs are taxes paid at home. Whatever their aims, sweeping import duties raise prices for the businesses and households that buy foreign goods and parts. Voters connected the duties to the prices they paid.
Second, the war multiplied the pain. The Iran conflict pushed fuel prices above four dollars a gallon, and higher fuel prices feed into almost everything else.
Third, the message clashed with experience. After the 2025 off-year elections, NBC News reported that many Republican leaders were insisting there was no affordability crisis. Telling voters that their struggles are exaggerated is a mistake that Democrats also made under Joe Biden, with the same result.
The deficit question
There is another uncomfortable number for both parties. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimates that the federal deficit for fiscal 2026 reached about two trillion dollars, around 6.2 per cent of GDP, with interest costs near 1.1 trillion. The gross national debt passed 40 trillion dollars in August. A new Democratic Congress will inherit this, and voters will judge Democrats on affordability just as harshly.
The lesson
The rule of American politics has not changed: no president can talk voters out of what they feel in their wallets. The midterms were not mainly an ideological rejection of conservatism. They were a verdict on results. That should worry the winners as much as the losers. Democrats ran on affordability; if prices are still high in 2028, the same voters can turn on them.
For African economies tied to the American market, the tariff wars carry a similar lesson. Trade policy made in one capital is paid for in many others, and those who pay often have no vote.

Leave a Reply