America After the Midterms, Part 9 of 10.
Donald Trump cannot run for president again. The 22nd Amendment to the US Constitution limits a president to two elected terms. The President has at times flirted with the idea of a third term, but he later backed away, saying he would be comfortable going into history as an “eight-year president”. The midterm defeat has turned the question of succession from a quiet calculation into an open contest.
Three explanations, three candidates
According to CNBC, the leading contenders are already competing to explain the defeat:
- Vice President JD Vance has pointed to the Iran war as the main reason Republicans lost. This puts distance between himself and the decision without attacking the President.
- Secretary of State Marco Rubio has defended the decision to strike Iran, positioning himself as the loyal guardian of the President’s foreign policy.
- Florida Governor Ron DeSantis argues that Republicans fought the wrong political battles.
Before the midterms, Vance was widely seen as the natural heir. CNN quoted a veteran New Hampshire Republican operative saying that the idea of Vance as a third Trump term now looks “problematic”. The Hill reported growing interest in Rubio. Rubio has said he would not run if Vance does. Nikki Haley has ruled herself out.
The President’s choice
Trump has kept his potential successors guessing. He has praised both men and floated the idea of a Vance-Rubio ticket. Fox News reported he told donors that “we need to elect JD.” By declining to anoint anyone, he keeps the party’s attention on himself, a familiar pattern from his career.
The lame-duck problem
A president in his final two years, facing a hostile Congress and approval in the low thirties, usually loses influence quickly. Members of Congress start looking to the next leader. Donors hedge their bets. Foreign governments wait out the clock.
Trump may defy that pattern. He still commands the loyalty of most Republican voters, and his endorsement can still decide primaries. But the softening of strong approval among his own supporters, discussed in Part 5, suggests his grip is weaker than it was.
What is likely to happen
Without predicting the future, several things seem probable:
- More executive action. With legislation blocked, presidents usually rely on executive orders, emergency powers and foreign policy, where Congress has the least control.
- Constant legal and political conflict with the new Congress, through investigations, vetoes, court battles and funding fights.
- A struggle over the party’s identity between those who want to keep Trump’s nationalist, tariff-driven, interventionist turn and those who want a return to restraint, or to more traditional conservatism.
The judgment of history
Supporters will remember a president who secured the border, reduced crime and challenged an establishment they distrusted. Critics will remember unauthorised wars, tariffs that raised prices, and pressure on independent institutions. The midterms show that, for now, a clear majority of Americans lean towards the second judgment. But history is long, and the final two years of a presidency can change a legacy.
A Pan-African observation
Constitutional term limits are not a formality. They are what force a movement to think about life after its founder. The 22nd Amendment means America will have a new president in January 2029, whatever happens. Those of us watching leaders across Africa use parliaments and amendments to extend their stay should notice how much stability a firm, respected term limit provides.

Leave a Reply